Chandigarh: The Punjab and Haryana high court has dismissed a review petition filed by the Punjab State Civil Supplies Corporation (PSCSC) against a judgement in favour of an employee, observing that the corporation’s approach was “manifestly disingenuous, discriminatory and wholly indefensible” as it had extended the benefit of the judgement to one similarly situated employee while arbitrarily denying it to another.Justice Harpreet Singh Brar also imposed costs of Rs 50,000 on the PSCSC, directing it to pay the amount to the employee, Pawan Kumar, within four weeks of receiving a certified copy of the order.The court was hearing an application seeking review of its March 10, 2026, judgement in a petition filed by Pawan Kumar.
The PSCSC had also filed intra-court appeals against the judgements passed in Kumar’s case and another employee, Jarmal Singh’s case, decided on April 27, 2026.During the hearing, counsel for the employee, advocates Padamkant Dwivedi and Ayushi, submitted that the corporation had already implemented the judgement in Jarmal Singh’s case, which was decided in terms of the judgement in Kumar’s case.The counsel contended that the PSCSC’s approach was disingenuous and highly iniquitous, submitting that extending the benefit of the judgement in one case while denying it in the other reflected arbitrariness, cherry-picking and favouritism, which have no place in matters of public employment.The court, while hearing the matter, examined the scope of review jurisdiction and observed that an order could be reviewed only on the grounds prescribed under Order XLVII Rule 1 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, namely discovery of new and important matter or evidence, an error apparent on the face of the record, or any other sufficient reason.Referring to the Supreme Court’s judgement in Kamlesh Verma versus Mayawati, the Bench reiterated the grounds on which review was maintainable and those on which it could not be entertained.The court also relied on the Supreme Court’s judgement in State of Telangana versus Mohd Abdul Qasim, 2024 INSC 310, which held that a decision, however erroneous, could not be a factor for review and could only be corrected in appeal.The court observed that the grounds urged in the review application were, in substance, grounds of appeal.Justice Brar observed, “Further still, in a review petition, it is not open to this court to re-appreciate the evidence and arrive at a different conclusion, even if such a conclusion is otherwise possible.”He stated, “Appreciation of the evidence on record falls within the domain of the appellate court, and once this court has recorded a finding of fact and arrived at a conclusion, the same cannot be assailed in review unless it is demonstrated that there is an error apparent on the face of the record or a ground analogous thereto.”Justice Brar added, “Permitting the review petitioner to re-agitate questions relating to appreciation of evidence would amount to converting the review petition into an appeal in disguise.
A decision, however erroneous, therefore, cannot by itself furnish a ground for review and may be corrected only in appeal.”The court further observed, “Under the garb of a review petition, this court cannot sit in appeal over its own judgement or undertake a fresh re-appreciation of the issues already considered and adjudicated.”Justice Brar said, “Further, the approach adopted by the applicant/respondents is manifestly disingenuous, discriminatory and wholly indefensible, inasmuch as they have extended the benefit of the judgement to one similarly situated employee while arbitrarily denying the same to another, despite both cases being governed by an identical legal principle.”The Bench observed, “Such selective implementation of judicial pronouncements, without any intelligible differentia or legally sustainable justification, is demonstrative of arbitrariness and pick-and-choose methodology, which are antithetical to the constitutional guarantees of equality and fairness enshrined under Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution of India.”It added, “The state and its instrumentalities, being model employers, cannot be permitted to adopt inconsistent and discriminatory standards in extending the benefits flowing from judicial adjudication to similarly situated employees.”Finding no error apparent on the face of the record or any other sufficient ground warranting review of its March 10 judgement, the court dismissed the review application.The high court further noted that the employee had been compelled to defend a second round of litigation despite there being no error apparent on the face of the record and imposed costs of Rs 50,000 on the corporation.The court also observed that in the event of non-compliance with the judgement under review, the employee would be at liberty to move an appropriate application under Article 215 of the Constitution for initiation of contempt proceedings.You Can Also Check: Gold Rate in Chandigarh | Silver Rate in Chandigarh | Bank Holidays in Chandigarh | Public Holidays in Chandigarh | Chandigarh AQI | Weather in Chandigarh | Petrol Price in Chandigarh | Diesel Price in Chandigarh | CNG Price in Chandigarh | LPG Price in ChandigarhStay updated with the latest Chandigarh news.
Download the TOI App.




